Pumpkin Spice Coffee Creamer – made with all natural ingredients – a perfectly delicious taste of fall!
Good morning, friends…..Happy Monday! (Is there such a thing??) I hope you had a wonderful weekend! Ours was a bit crazier than usual, with two soccer games and two birthday parties and a kitchen painting project and, of course, the Packer game…..all good things, for sure, but crazy nonetheless!
Busy weekends always leave me wishing we could have just one more day. A day where we have nothing planned and we can just figure it out as we go. It’s funny – I used to live for plans – but now that we have kids I find myself wanting more and more to have NOTHING on our calendar! (Probably because it never happens – ha!)
The other thing busy weekends leave me wanting? A warm, delicious, strong cup of coffee to start my week. Okay, let’s be honest. When do I NOT want a warm, delicious, strong cup of coffee? But what makes this one even more delicious is the creamer. I’ve been loving pumpkin lately, so this Pumpkin Spice Coffee Creamer is exactly what I’ve been craving. It’s made with just 4 simple ingredients and couldn’t be easier to shake together. It’s the perfect blend of sugar and spice, the perfect taste of fall.
Whether your fall weekends have been crazy busy like this past one, or slow and relaxed like I’d like ours to be…..you can’t go wrong with pumpkin! And you most certainly can’t go wrong with coffee. Especially on a Monday morning! I hope you have a great start to your week! (I know I will!!!!)

Ingredients
- 1 c. half & half
- 1/4 c. pumpkin butter
- 2 Tbsp. sugar
- 1/2 tsp. pumpkin pie spice
- *I purchased pumpkin butter at Trader Joe's. Recipe can be made alternatively with 1/4 c. pumpkin pie filling not pumpkin puree and 1/4 c. sugar instead of 2 Tbsp.
Instructions
- Combine all ingredients in a small container and stir until sugar is dissolved and flavors are blended.
Looking for more delicious coffee creamer recipes? Check out these ones:







Omg, I love this!! Hello, my name is Tina and I love coffee. I don’t like the flavored store bought creamers but I know that I love this homemade version. I just need to find me some pumpkin butter! Have a lovely week. 🙂
Sounds delicious to me!! ~ Catherine
I’ve been waiting for this post, Cathy! Yum! Thank you:)
Haha – all for you, Meaghan! 🙂
PS…I LOVE this creamer! It’s not too sweet and has all the pumpkin spicey-ness anyone would want! try. it. now. (and while you’re at it…try Cathy’s holiday creamers, too….omg)
Sounds great! Just wondering where you purchase pumpkin butter? I am hoping this isn’t just a Midwest thing (I am from Iowa).
Hi Julie,
I got my pumpkin butter from Trader Joe’s….I’m not sure what stores sell it but I’m sure there are others! (And/or a fall farmer’s market!) I also just updated the recipe to include a version made with pumpkin pie filling in place of the pumpkin butter – it tastes almost identical! Hope you enjoy!
Cathy
Perfect creamer and I love it has simple ingredients….. I’m not awake until I’ve had my coffee!!
Cathy, oh, thank you so much for this recipe – my daughter will be thrilled because pumpkin spice is her favorite! 🙂
I need to make my own creamer, so easy and less expensive! Love this recipe Cathy!
I’ve been wanting to make my own creamer at home! This is a great idea.
This pumpkin spice coffee creamer looks delish!
I really don’t know how on earth you manage such busy schedule! But I’m so glad you can relax with a cup of coffee with this amazing creamer! Pinned to my pumpkin board!
My blood type is coffee! 🙂 I am a huge fan of flavored creamers …. and all things pumpkin. I think I love you for this recipe – I have to make it soon! Pinned and stumbled!
My coffee so needs this right now! I’ve never made my own creamer so I’m definitely going to try this one along with the other holiday creamers you’ve created! More coffee, please!
How long does this last? Any special storing instructions – covered? Sealed? Thank you!